Student Loans or Buying a Home? Why I Bought First and Rented Out a Room

By Rick Albert | April 14, 2017

Student Loans or Buy a Home? Start Small | Rick Albert

Student loan debt keeps growing. The New York Fed reports about $1.66 trillion in total U.S. student loan debt in the first quarter of 2026. When I first wrote this in 2016, it was $1.2 trillion. I was part of that group, and I still had a choice to make.

In December 2010, six months after college, my payments kicked in. My loans were unsubsidized, so interest had been building the whole time I was in school. I made my payments, and sometimes a large extra one. Then, in 2015, I had money saved and two options: be debt free, or buy a condo. I bought the condo.

Why I bought

I compared Los Angeles rents to what I would pay for a mortgage, taxes, insurance and HOA dues. I would pay the same or more to rent. Condo prices were also rising fast. Even if I paid off my loans first, I would need a bigger down payment later, and I would be chasing the market.

What happened next

  • I rented my second bedroom to a friend. After I refinanced to remove mortgage insurance, his rent covered half of my bills.
  • I paid less to own than I would have paid to rent a small studio.
  • My mortgage payment stayed the same while rents around me kept climbing.
  • Each payment lowered what I owed. The condo appreciated 20% to 25%, based on recent sales and past appraisals at the time.
  • Because I wasn’t paying rent, I paid off all my other debt.

That condo was my first step into investing. It taught me the basics I teach now: let the property carry some of its own cost, and build equity while you live there. I wrote about this idea in What Is House Hacking?, and you can see how I help investors on my Invest page.

What is different today

Mortgage rates were much lower in 2015. Freddie Mac reported 7.40% for a 30-year fixed on October 15, 2026, so the math is tighter. Here is where I would look now:

  • Rent out part of your home. A spare room or an ADU can still cover a real share of the bills.
  • Look at assumable mortgages. In some cases you can take over the seller’s existing loan, often at a lower rate than today’s. You still have to qualify, and you need cash for the gap between the price and the loan balance. See my page on assuming a mortgage.
  • If you already own, find out what your equity can do for you with a free equity review.

If you sell a home you have owned and lived in as your main home for at least 2 of the last 5 years, you may be able to keep up to $250,000 of the profit tax free ($500,000 if married filing jointly). Check with your CPA.

After a few years I leveraged the condo by using a home equity line of credit (HELOC) and used it as a down payment on the second house hack. Seven years after I bought the condo, I ended up selling for about double what I paid for it and started my journey investing out of state into the multifamily world. But there is no way I could have started investing had I not bought that condo to begin with.

Every situation is different, so talk to the right people before you decide. This is my story, and it came with a happy ending. If you want to talk about yours, contact me.

Photo credit: “Hand And Money Staircase,fingers Walking Up On Stacks Of Coins,f…” by jk1991

Tags:

Comments are closed

© 2026 Rick Albert, Broker Associate | DRE #01884303 | LAMERICA Real Estate | Equal Housing Opportunity | Privacy Policy